What 700+ WhatsApp interviews with teachers and school leaders reveal about supporting learners and grade progression decisions
Image credits: Sandra Dans from Studio Philippines
By: Department of Education of the Philippines, Colectiv, and IDinsight
Teachers and school leaders described grade repetition as having both potential benefits and drawbacks. Some saw it as an opportunity for learners to strengthen foundational skills, while others expressed concern that, without effective support, it could reinforce a sense of failure, undermine confidence, and increase the risk of disengagement or dropout.
Across the Philippines, the Department of Education (DepEd) has made strengthening foundational learning a key priority so that learners develop the competencies they need as they progress through school. To respond to different learner needs, Philippine public schools draw on a range of approaches, including the Academic Recovery and Accessible Learning (ARAL) Programme, Alternative Delivery Modes (ADM), and teacher- and school-initiated interventions.
Our interviews with teachers and school leaders highlighted a recurring challenge: identifying learners early enough, understanding why each is falling behind, and matching them with support that can change their trajectory before promotion or repetition decisions are made.
School leader interviews
Teacher interviews
interview questions answered
📋 What we did
IDinsight and Colectiv conducted two complementary rounds of AI-assisted WhatsApp interviews across DepEd Philippines schools in 17 regions of the Philippines. Participants responded remotely through WhatsApp, with an AI interviewer asking questions and follow-up probes based on a semi-structured interview guide. We then analyzed responses across the full sample to identify recurring themes and patterns.
Three hundred school leaders (principals and teachers-in-charge) discussed the expectations they set for teachers, how they review and document progression decisions, and how schools organize support for learners at risk. A further 414 teachers described how they identify learning gaps in the classroom, track learners’ progress and respond to the practical and emotional consequences of remediation and repetition.
Together, the interviews provided both a school-level and classroom-level view of learner progression.
School leaders focused particularly on consistency, accountability, and defensible decision-making. Teachers revealed in greater detail what determines whether support works from one day to the next.
Six findings emerged across our interviews
“Our basis for passing our students is whether they can read well, understand what they’re reading, know how to count, and can do the ‘four fundamental operations’.” — Teacher at a public elementary school in Luzon
School leaders and teachers frequently looked beyond final grades, paying particular attention to whether learners had the foundational skills needed for the next grade.
Reading with comprehension was the clearest threshold, particularly in the early years. Basic numeracy was also central. Because these foundational skills enable learners to access content across the curriculum and provide the building blocks for future learning, persistent difficulties in reading and numeracy were seen as warnings of future failure rather than weaknesses in a single subject.
While teachers and school leaders viewed repetition as appropriate in some cases, they carefully distinguished this from recommending repetition for every learner performing below grade level. Participants described repetition as most defensible when additional time, combined with purposeful support, offered a realistic route to mastery. At the same time, some expressed concern that promoting learners with unresolved foundational gaps could defer the problem and make recovery harder in the next grade.
“We began by examining multiple forms of evidences like academic records (test scores, quarterly grades, and performance tasks), diagnostic assessments (results from remedial reading and math interventions), behavioral and social factors (the learner’s classroom participation, motivation, and emotional readiness), and family input (we invited the parents to share observations about the child’s study habits and home support).” — School leader at a public elementary school in Mindanao
Teachers and school leaders often described fair progression decisions as requiring more than academic performance alone. But the interviews also showed considerable variation in how broadly and consistently schools gathered and used evidence. While grades remained an important starting point, some participants described also considering formative assessments, classroom observation, intervention records, attendance, participation, emotional readiness, and information from families.
The important distinction was between identifying that a learner was behind and understanding why. A low reading score, for example, might reflect a specific skills gap, but it could also be linked to irregular attendance, illness, difficult home circumstances, or more persistent learning needs. These different causes called for different responses: targeted practice in some cases, support to restore attendance in others, or specialist assessment and adapted instruction where difficulties persisted. Understanding why a learner was behind was therefore critical to choosing the right response.
“Although remedial sessions are conducted at school, if there is no follow-up at home and the child’s attendance is not consistent, it feels like the remediation always goes back to the beginning. Because of this, the child’s motivation is also affected.” — Teacher at a public elementary school in Luzon
Teachers particularly emphasized how easily learning gains disappeared when support was interrupted. Regular attendance gave learners continued access to instruction, practice, feedback and assessment, while home routines could help sustain learning between school days.
Participants also described how some of the learners most in need of support faced the greatest difficulties accessing it consistently. Poverty, work, caregiving, transport difficulties, illness and limited adult support could all disrupt learning. Weak performance could therefore sometimes reflect unequal access to learning opportunities rather than ability or effort alone.
School leaders described parent contact, home visits, flexible schedules, feeding support and community involvement as ways to restore continuity. These approaches appeared most useful when they helped learners return to sustained participation in learning.
“In our school, what most limits the more frequent or effective use of ARAL and ADM are capacity and resource constraints, rather than willingness to implement them.” — School leader at a public elementary school in Mindanao
Teachers and school leaders described ARAL, ADM, one-on-one tutoring, and other interventions as important pathways to support learners before repetition was considered. They also stressed that a program’s availability did not necessarily mean learners could access effective support consistently.
Effective remediation, they said, depended on protected time, appropriate materials, sufficient staffing, tailored or small-group instruction and regular monitoring. Large classes, administrative workloads, limited budgets and staff shortages made provision fragile. Support might be offered, but not frequently or intensively enough to close the gap.
The same response was also unlikely to work for every learner. Support was most useful when it addressed the particular skills or circumstances holding a learner back and connected classroom instruction, family engagement and follow-up around a clear recovery plan. A central challenge was therefore not simply willingness to provide support, but schools’ capacity to turn available programs into dependable pathways for individual learners.
“If the child is just, so to speak, deserving to be passed and only a few things need to be adjusted, I would recommend to the teachers to first give the child sufficient remediation activities, and if the child’s grade is really not passable, then the child really should be retained because they will also have difficulty in the next grade level.” — School leader at a public elementary school in Luzon
Across the interviews, participants generally rejected both automatic promotion and automatic repetition. Instead, they described progression as a case-by-case judgment intended to protect learners from unnecessary retention while avoiding advancement without the skills needed to succeed.
School leaders placed particular emphasis on ensuring that intervention, parent engagement and structured review came before retention. They described using assessment records, intervention logs, home visits and parent conferences to make decisions more transparent and demonstrate that support had been attempted. Teachers described the same principle as a visible recovery process, with several arguing that repetition was more defensible when difficulties had been identified early, targeted support had been provided, and substantial gaps remained.
Participants also pointed to conditional promotion, summer remediation and alternative pathways as possible middle routes for learners who had progressed but still needed support. The common principle was that promotion or repetition should follow a sustained effort to help the learner recover, rather than become the consequence of support arriving too late.
“When repetition is presented as failure, learners lose motivation. When it is framed as a supported second chance with clear goals, it becomes more constructive.” — Teacher at a public elementary school in Mindanao
Teachers and school leaders described very different ways in which learners could respond to repetition. When learners experienced it as public failure, comparison or labeling, participants reported shame, withdrawal, avoidance and loss of confidence. Some suggested these risks could be especially pronounced for over-age learners and those separated from their peers.
Others described more constructive responses when learners understood the decision, had clear goals and could see how additional support might make success achievable. Familiar work sometimes allowed learners to rebuild confidence, but this depended on repetition offering a meaningfully different and supportive experience.
Teachers highlighted the importance of small successes, patient feedback, reassurance and recognition of effort. School leaders emphasized counseling, respectful communication and inclusive school practices. Their accounts suggest that motivation is not simply something learners either possess or lack. It can be shaped by whether support makes progress visible, protects dignity, and gives learners a credible reason to believe they can succeed.
🔑 The takeaway
The most important promotion decision is made long before the school year ends.
The interviews suggest that grade repetition is often the end point of a longer process: identifying that a learner is falling behind, understanding why, providing support, and deciding whether that support has worked.
Existing pathways such as ARAL and ADM provide important routes for learning recovery and continued participation. But the interviews suggest their effectiveness can depend on a series of timely decisions: who needs help, the main barrier each learner faces, and the response most likely to address it. A learner with a specific literacy gap, for example, needs something different from one whose progress is being disrupted by absence, difficult home circumstances, or loss of confidence. Support must also be accessible and confidence-building, giving learners opportunities to experience progress without feeling labeled or left behind.
6 December 2024
19 September 2025
11 February 2025
3 December 2024
5 November 2024
21 July 2025
21 November 2023
21 September 2023